YOU can help expand it. Guests are encouraged to do so primarily by adding sections, not by editing the existing ones. More ideas, and some possible material are on the related discussion page |
The Problem, put simply
It takes much more time for a nervous impulse to travel from the sole of our feet to our brain while walking than to see them walking.
Still, both types of sensations, tactile and visual, reach our consciousness at the same moment of perception.
The Allegory of the Five Senses, by Simon de Vos (1640) - Also gives a good idea of what our hypothetical homunculus or yourself-in-yourself has to deal with every day, confronted with a variety of sensory inputs
In other words, perceiving the touch and sight of an event is like receiving an email and a postcard that were sent simultaneously. How could the email and the 'snail mail' arrive at the same time? In physiology, they do.1
With what we know of the complexity of the simplest actions or thought processes in daily lives, knowing the speed of nerve impulses, we can already say that it is impossible to take synaptic transmission, the interaction of neurons between each other through simple chemical messengers (neurotransmitters), as the fundamental mode of communication in the brain: reading each of these words would take you seconds or minutes.2
Walking, and looking at oneself walking, is one of those simple actions that only some neuroscientists and philosophers may focus on to solve some esoteric logical problem and etch new theories. But the fact is that, in general, they are not so good at it. Consider the common, but fiercely disingenuous, hypothesis that some problem-solvers have come up with: nerve transmission is necessary to perception; different senses transmit information at different speeds; ergo, some part of ourselves make us believe that the sensations are simultaneous! It seems that René Descartes' little genius is back, this time to fool us into ignoring that when our foot hits the ground, we first see it, and then feel it; to make us believe that our world is a single one, when in fact it is nothing more than a variety of streams of information entering our various different physicochemical channels.
Of course, no philosopher or neuroscientist, has mapped, ontologically or neurophysiologically, this Matrix-like phantasy.
Society continues to evolve under the neurochemical, synaptic, paradigm. Happiness, love, genius (and their counterparts, depression, indifference and conformism) remain molecular events, or at best, sociologically determined molecular events.
What is implied, in truth, in this ancient (in Science time) riddle?
That, when you see and feel your feet touching the ground, or your hand clicking the mouse, your senses only fullfil a secondary role, like as many court ushers, after the 'real' action occurred. Or/and, perhaps, that information can travel, like it appears to do in the quantum realm, backwards in time?3
- 1[*
http://www.quantumconsciousness.org/views/TimeFlies.html Time Flies (Backwards?)] Stuart Hameroff, M.D. Quantum Consciousness - 2"As a synaptic transmission takes at least 0.5 ms, transmission across thousands of synapses may take hundreds or thousands of milliseconds. The transmission of nerve impulses along an axon is also relatively slow, between 0.5 m/sec and 120 m/sec. As an example, more than fifty percent of nerve fibers in the corpus callosum are unmyelinated slow fibers with a transmission speed of 0.5 m/sec. [[br]] For this reason, we must search for another, more rapid mechanism of neuronal interactions to explain the speed of some fast reactions in the nervous system. Synaptic transmission and axonal transfer of nerve impulses are too slow to organize coordinated activity in large areas of the central nervous system. Numerous observations confirm this view." From: Stanislav Reinis, Robert F. Holub and Pavel Smrz (2005)
http://watarts.uwaterloo.ca/~sreinis/quantum.html A quantum hypothesis of brain function and consciousness][[br]] "Various aspects of sensory percepts and volitional actions are processed in different cortical regions within single sensory modalities (e.g., visual shape, motion, color), among different sensory modalities (e.g., sight, touch and sound), and at different times, separated from each other by 80 ms or so.14 But our conscious percepts are somehow “bound” into unified objects and simultaneous events." in Anesthesiology 2006; 105:400 –12 The Entwined Mysteries of Anesthesia and Consciousness - Is There a Common Underlying Mechanism? Stuart R. Hameroff, M.D. - 3[*
http://www.quantumconsciousness.org/views/TimeFlies.html Time Flies (Backwards?)] Stuart Hameroff, M.D. Quantum Consciousness


